A World Where Your Vote Will Count
by Paul VanRaden
©
2004
See also:
"All
those other constitutions are documents that say:
'We,
the government, allow the people the following rights,'
and
our constitution says
'We,
the people, allow the government the following privileges and rights.' "
Ronald
Reagan, February 5, 1981
Constitutions
The
Constitutional reform comes slow now, while society changes fast.
Recent amendments to the
Problems
The
1) Two different sets of law-makers (the house of representatives
and the senate) vote separately on two different sets of bills. Further changes
are introduced by conference committees. After this, the executive branch (the
president) may veto the work of the legislative branch, who then may vote again
to over-ride the veto. This whole process is slow, inefficient, and hard for
voters to monitor.
2) The principle of one person, one vote is ignored in the senate.
Each state gets the same number of votes (2) in the
3) The
4) In presidential elections, the most popular candidate does not
win. Recent examples when the first choice was defeated by the second choice
were in 2000 when most voters chose Al Gore but George
W. Bush became president and in 2016 when most voters chose Hillary Clinton but
Donald Trump became president. Again, the bad compromise in article 2, section
1 of the 1789 constitution gave voters in small states more influence than they
deserve when electing the nation’s president.
5) The titles of many office holders are not very descriptive. The
vice-president of the United States is the president of the senate, but rarely
actually presides over the senate. In the U.S., the secretaries are the bosses
over the executive departments. In many other countries, ministers are in
charge of governments.
6) The
The United Nations charter has many, more serious problems.
1) In the U.N. charter, only nations count, not people. The basic
principle of one person, one vote is never used at the United Nations. When
votes are counted in the security council and in the general assembly, a
nation’s population size and number of voters are always ignored.
2) A dictator that won’t count votes within his own nation gets to
vote at the United Nations, and his vote is given equal credit to a vote from
any elected government.
3) Five of the nations that won the second world war (the
4) The five permanent members of the security council each
have veto power over resolutions, amendments to the charter, or appointment of
the secretary-general. This severely limits the United Nations’ ability to act, to
change, or to choose strong leaders.
You
say you want a revolution ...
You
say you'll change the constitution.
from
the song Revolution by The Beatles, 1968
Votes
Will your vote make a difference? About ½ of Americans already
have decided that taking an hour or two to vote, even once every four years, is
not worth their time. Only about 1/3 of Americans vote for senators and
representatives in the elections held every two years between presidential
elections. In the
When the votes are counted to elect a president, or a governor, or
a senator, or any election where one winner is chosen from each district, an
individual’s vote in fact makes no difference unless the election is a tie or
is decided by only one or two votes. Only in these very rare cases does each
vote make a difference. In large state or national elections where millions of
people vote, the chances are nearly 100% that your vote will not decide
who wins and who gets power, because the winner will beat the loser by more than
just your vote.
If the election is not very close, why bother to vote? If your
favorite candidates have no chance to win, why should you vote for them. If
none of the candidates share your beliefs, why should you vote at all?
Elections
Election laws will be changed, and then your vote count will
count. Solutions are simple.
1) Elected officials will have power only in proportion to the
vote count, not the census count. If you vote for your representatives, their
influence in the government will increase. Their votes will get more credit
because you voted for them, not simply because you exist and were counted in a
census.
2) Winner-take-all elections will be replaced by proportional representation
and power sharing such as used in modern democracies. Voters in the democratic
nations of Europe, Asia, South America, and
3) One person will get one vote and all votes will count equally.
People will share power based on the number of votes counted, not the area of
land controlled. States and territories will have power only in proportion to
the number of voters that live there.
4) Election laws that make sense for governing cities, states, and
nations will also be used for governing the world. International law will be
based on the same basic rules of democracy. Power will be shared by the people
of the world according to population size and number of voters within each
nation. The United Nations Charter will be completely revised so that each
voter in the world will be counted.
5) No national government will be allowed to vote in international
elections if it does not allow its own citizens to vote. United Nations
delegates will be directly elected by the people instead of appointed by the
national government, similar to election of
All adults will have the right to vote in future elections, but
many can’t vote today. Some national governments in Africa and
"It
is preposterous to presume that the people of one generation
can
lay down the best and only rules of government
for
all who are to come after them"
Ulysses
S. Grant, 1885
Solutions
Real change really is possible, and progress today should be
easier than in the past. In revolutionary wars, civil wars, and world wars,
brave people gave their lives to give others the right to vote. But violence is
not needed for change to occur. After only a cold war, many communist
governments disappeared. White people finally did vote yes to let black people
vote. Men finally did vote yes to let women vote.
People in small states finally will vote yes to let people
in big states have equal representation. Elected officials finally will take
power away from kings, queens, dictators for life, military rulers, and
single-party states. Constitutions will be written, amended, re-written, and
adopted by the people. Recent work to develop a constitution for
Politics could become a subject worthy of study. Politician could
be a job title that people could look up to and that many would want to compete
for. Salaries and bonuses for politicians could be increased to be competitive
with other top professions if new election laws provide law-makers that better
represent and are respected by the populations they serve. With modern
communication, lawmakers might continue to live in their districts and cast
votes by e-mail instead of living in capital cities and concentrating power
there. Democracy could evolve instead of being stuck in the past.
“We
have it in our power to begin the world over again”
Thomas
Paine, Common Sense, January 10, 1776
Conclusions
The idea of democracy began thousands of years ago, but most
nations did not have democratic governments until recent decades. The laws of
democratic nations have improved greatly over the last two centuries, but still
have some very serious flaws. This report attempted to solve some remaining
problems of democracy by proposing new laws to govern people and nations.
Americans declared independence from the King of Great Britain in
1776. In today’s more democratic world and global economy, Americans should
reverse their revolution. They should sign a declaration of dependence on the
rest of the world. They should admit that in the age of global travel, trade,
and communication, we all affect and are affected by the people outside of our
own nation. The citizens of earth are now connected, and our laws should
recognize our dependence.
Even very good laws become stale after 250 years. Americans will
revise the
The United Nations charter must be revised sooner than that.
People everywhere already agree that democracy works within nations, and they
will agree that the principles of democracy can work nearly as well across
nations. National governments will begin to follow international law. Words
spoken by dictators will be replaced by laws written by elected officials.
Anarchy and totalitarianism and will both be replaced by effective, controlled
international government.
Officials will be elected to make and to enforce international
laws and judges will be appointed to hear individual cases so that each of us
does not have to take the law into our own hands or vote on every proposed new
law. We expect that the actions of elected officials will represent the wishes
of all people, or we will get new officials and new rules.
Action
Excuse me, Mr. Chairman. Will the senator from